The Truth About Protein: More Won’t Hurt You—And It Won’t Make You Fat

Greg Nagaye • March 17, 2025

Forget What the Dietitians Say: More Protein Won’t Hurt You—And It Won’t Make You Fat

For years, conventional wisdom (and many registered dietitians) have told us that eating too much protein is unnecessary, potentially harmful, and might even lead to weight gain. But the latest research tells a different story. Not only is extra protein not harmful, but it may also have surprising benefits—including building muscle even without exercise.


A recent study by Bray et al. found that when feeding a group of untrained individuals over 230 grams of protein per day, they gained an extra 6.6 pounds of muscle—even without lifting a single weight. That’s right—more protein led to muscle growth, even in the absence of resistance training. This completely dismantles the outdated belief that only those actively training benefit from higher protein intake.


But what about those who are already trained? A study by Leaf et al. examined the effects of adding an extra 800 calories worth of protein to the diets of trained individuals. The result? No added fat gain. This means that consuming additional protein—even in large amounts—does not lead to unwanted weight gain, as long as the extra calories come from protein rather than carbs or fats.


So, where does this leave us? It’s simple: eat more protein. The fear-mongering around high-protein diets is outdated and unsupported by the latest research. If you want to maximize muscle growth, optimize recovery, and keep body fat in check, increasing your protein intake is a no-brainer.


Forget the myths. More protein won’t hurt you. It won’t turn to fat. And if the science tells us anything, it might just be the key to building muscle—whether you train or not.


Coach Greg Nagaye MS, CSCS

IFBB Pro

By Chrissy Garcia-Nagaye May 25, 2025
Leucine: The Muscle-Preserving Hack Every Fit Body Needs This Bikini Season
By Greg Nagaye May 22, 2025
You can’t out-train stress
By Flex Wheeler May 21, 2025
Are You Spending Too Much Time in the Gym? Here's Why Less Might Be More
By Flex Wheeler May 18, 2025
The Simple Trio That Slows Aging: What the Biscoff-Ferarri Study Reveals
By Greg Nagaye May 15, 2025
How Tariffs Are Quietly Raising the Cost of Fitness
By Chrissy Garcia-Nagaye May 14, 2025
Get Bikini Ready!
By Flex Wheeler May 11, 2025
If I Haven’t Convinced You to Start Lifting Weights Yet, This Might Do It
By Chrissy Garcia-Nagaye May 8, 2025
Hormone Balance as We Age: What You Need to Know (Especially About Testosterone)
By Greg Nagaye May 5, 2025
How to Boost Muscle Growth Between Meals: The Power of Leucine
By Flex Wheeler April 28, 2025
The Importance of Having — and Using — Your Health Insurance
More Posts